The Promposal: Is it Modern-Day Chivalry or Nonsense?
It’s that time of year when teenage boys around America are expected to put on a production to ask a girl to the traditional high school dance.
Is the Promposal modern-day chivalry or plain nonsense?
After a long day of school and varsity baseball practice, my son and his friend trudged through our house carrying an armload of art supplies and poster boards.
When my son should be spending time on his physics homework or hanging out with his grandparents who are visiting from out of town, he has to design a sloganed poster to invite his girlfriend to the upcoming junior prom.
My parents, who attended high school prom together, can’t believe this is what’s going on today. Knowing teenage boys don’t naturally do this sort of thing, my Dad asked his grandson and his friend if they feel like decorating posters?
“Not really. But, the girls want us to do it.”
Sure they like the girl. Sure they want to take her to the dance. It’s been a high school rite of passage through the generations. Neither my Grandpa, my Dad nor my husband ever had to invite their date to prom with anything other than their words, so why are our sons now expected to conjure up a themed presentation to ask a girl to the dance?
As if teenage guys don’t have enough on their plate today, they must now come up with a cheesy proposal production as is the societal norm. He’d better not think of asking a girl to the dance without at least a decorated poster board in hand or he would be considered unthoughtful, uncaring or rude.
Why are our sons expected to put on a proposal production to ask a date to prom?
What happened to just a good guy asking a sweet girl to the high school dance?
How come that’s no longer acceptable?
Why do we insist on turning what should be a simple invitation into a production today?
Because there wouldn’t be anything post-worthy for social media if there weren’t a production, and we all know how much everyone loves a good curated photo for the feed.
And forget the decorated poster board. Some take it to another level buying oversized teddy bears, shoes, jewelry, and the list goes on. I’m sure the bigger, the better. Check out this post or your kids’ social media feeds if you don’t believe me.
The promposal production seems like another great way to try and one-up each other too. Oh, your guy only decorated a poster for you? Well, check out what my man (or his Mom) did for me…. and the comparison game is on. Just what our youth need.
I’m having a tough time wrapping my head around the concept and why we’re accepting this nonsense to be commonplace now.
What type of marriage proposal are girls going to expect one day if they need a song and dance to accept an invitation to a high school dance?
Our daughter said she thinks the promposal idea is “cute.” I explained to her that it’s adorable when she and her girlfriends make posters for one another’s birthdays and bring them to middle school to celebrate. There is nothing cute about expecting a young man to design a presentation to ask you to prom.
Let’s stop putting pressure on kids to have to put on a post-worthy show for what should be a simple invitation to a timeless high school event.
Let’s put our efforts into raising confident and kind young men and women who don’t need a showy production to feel good about themselves or to enjoy their lives.
Let’s begin to tell our kids that a post-worthy promposal production is not necessary.
I can’t agree with you more! It’s not even really sincere since i’m sure most girls know “the mom” has done it….I’ve told my boys, “not THIS Mom” – ha!
The one thing that I do like… it forces the “askee” to actually *know* something about the other person. Two of my kids have had Promposals….and both were cute and thoughtful and really relevant to who they are. So….hopefully this is just a fad (like the super-short dresses of a decade ago?). It is harmless….but stupid.
not everyone expects a promposal. the people you see flaunting theirs on social media are only a certain kind of person. a solid majority of the people i know either just ask normally or go solo/with friends
I just followed the link to the promposal ideas. I cannnnooootttt believe someone has a whole list of ideas. Wowzers.